Wednesday, December 06, 2006

Mike Mace created some buzz a few weeks ago when he blogged the following:
Ed Colligan, CEO of Palm, gave a talk this morning. Afterward I asked him if we'll see next year the secret project that Jeff Hawkins has been working on. "Yes," he said, and moved immediately to another question.
I pinged him this morning to see if he could say anything else about the talk he heard, writing "I realize that Colligan probably didn't have anything else to say about their still-secret project," to which he replied:
Nope, but I have a tidbit for you. I was talking to someone who supposedly knows someone who knows stuff, and I mentioned the Hawkins project.

"Is that different from the Linux tablet they're doing?" this person said.

If I had to guess today, based on the very fragmentary hints I've heard, I'd expect:

--Something slightly larger than a handheld.

--WiFi based.

--A large amount of local storage.

--Syncs with, and acts as a light client to, your PC (and perhaps also a data store on the Web).

The key thing I don't know is what specific problems the device would be designed to solve. The rumors I've heard so far are more focused on hardware features. The "zen" is in the solution.

Well, he's right about that. As much of a mobile computing enthusiast as I am, and as much as I've seen how the technology can have a huge impact on how my clients are able to conduct business, I personally remain stubbornly dissatisfied with every device I've tried out there. Various smartphones and PDAs have tantalized me with the possibility of getting all my "stuff" under control and on my person, but as much as I like them they don't really help me with the fundamental problem. The best description of what I need is the "Info Pad" idea that Mike floated back in the Spring. But no one has really developed a device close enough to the Info Pad for me to put my whole life onto it and have it work. It's just amazing to me, because I know so many people that are in the same boat.

Last night I ran across an amusing article that C|Net published back in July that highlighted how little the major players in the mobile device market have learned about what different people really need from their mobile technology. It was a face-off between the Samsung Q1 UMPC and—get this—the Apple Newton MessageBook 2000.

The 10-year-old Newton won the match.

I suffer daily—literally, physically suffer—for the lack of a device that helps me keep everything in my life together, accessible, and on my person: email, handwritten notes, whiteboards, reams of articles, projects, drawings, diagrams and docs that are spread across multiple PCs, desks, bags, and file cabinets in three different offices across two different states. I'm dying here, and I am praying for someone to deliver me from this hell.

What Mike Mace describes gives me hope that Palm could be the one.

Comments

Interesting.
You want the infopad.
I want the carrypad.

Both devices are well defined but do not exist.

I have learnt over the last 8 months of research into UMPCs that pretty much everyone's ideal device doesn't exist. I mean, who on earth needs an Ipod when most mobile phones come with a player. A successful device largely depends on the need created for it by a marketing plan don't you think?

That should not stop us from trying to find our ideal devices though. Far from it. We all need to put our ideas forward in order for designers to learn that there is no one-size-fits all approach to mobile computing.
Our (people that know what they want) biggest problem though is that 95% of people don't know what they want and will be led by marketing!

Looking forward to Palms device. Whatever it is.

Steve.
Carrypad.com

Posted by chippy at Wednesday, December 06, 2006 16:09:13

Steve wrote: "A successful device largely depends on the need created for it by a marketing plan, don't you think"?

Nice to have your comments, Steve!

I believe that good marketing (i.e. the kind that really works) helps people discover needs they might not have known they had, or that they were unable to articulate. And yeah, I think that marketing (together with correct judgement about what that undiscovered need is!) is what will make a new device class successful.

You mention the iPod. I don't think mobile phones were where they needed to be (techically or culturally) when the iPod craze took off for them to substitute perfectly for a standalone player. I don't think that was a case of marketing leading consumers astray as much as Apple understanding that a dirt-simple, single-purposed, elegantly designed music player that syncs with a big, cheap, online music store was something people would go for. Now that mobile phones are starting to be used in the culture for much more than placing phone calls it's not surprising that the iPod is taking a hit. But that doesn't mean people were "fooled" by Apple's marketing and now "wising up." It's that the culture has changed so they're ready for a new way to carry their music with them.

Totally agree that mobile computing is not a one-size-fits-all affair. There are lots of niches possible, and as mobile technology continues to work its way more into the culture I think lots of distinctive new classes of devices will start to emerge.

I enjoy your site, by the way! But what's your definition of a "carrypad" if it's not a device that exists yet?

Posted by cervezas at Wednesday, December 06, 2006 17:46:56

You're both right in that mobile computing has many niches. That's why the "Palm-is-doomed" meme that circulates the 'net is so laughable; the market for mobile computing devices is only going to get bigger and more diversified, and gadget geeks such as ourselves are soon going to have more options than we can poke a stick at.

If anyone's going to get this "infopad" idea right, it's going to be Apple or Palm. They both have the same design philosophy; simple, user-friendly devices. Simplicity is all the rage nowadays...

Posted by freakout at Wednesday, December 06, 2006 19:34:36

"I believe that good marketing (i.e. the kind that really works) helps people discover needs they might not have known they had"

Yup. A combo of good research and good advertising is the best.

The carrypad was the device that I decided I needed about a year ago. Long before I started the blog. Before MS UMPCs existed too.

It centers around the very important need for an 800x480 screen which enables the rich browsing and web based application usage. 640x480 would be enough but no-one programs for 640x480 in the commercial web world. Its got a keyboard (to enable creative input, much as your tablet idea) and includes the tablet. It doesn't necessarily run XP or any x86-based OS. It just needs to have a simple user interface. I often wonder if Win CE or Win POS would be enough as long as the browser was rich (to ie7/FF2 standards.) but there would be a need for users to add new programs which make WinCE difficult. I usually end up with WM, S60 or something like Maemo as the ideal OS/Gui.

I recently decided that hi-speed cellular data is a must now. Wifi hotspots are just not taking off, are a security problem and are often expensive.

I wrote an article about the concept in Feb (http://www.carrypad.com/con...) and am still searching for the ideal device!

Regards
Steve

Posted by chippy at Thursday, December 07, 2006 04:10:56

My two cents

Cell Computer Project: http://geocities.com/gene_t...

Regards,

Michael

Posted by genetechnics at Saturday, January 20, 2007 05:56:08

Add Comment

Comments must be approved before being published. Thank you!